Snickers wars reveal the enduring perversity of human behaviour - FT中文网
登录×
电子邮件/用户名
密码
记住我
请输入邮箱和密码进行绑定操作:
请输入手机号码,通过短信验证(目前仅支持中国大陆地区的手机号):
请您阅读我们的用户注册协议隐私权保护政策,点击下方按钮即视为您接受。
FT商学院

Snickers wars reveal the enduring perversity of human behaviour

Market failures occur because consumers are not the all-knowing rational agents that appear in economic models
00:00

{"text":[[{"start":null,"text":"

"}],[{"start":9.62,"text":"What can be done to cut inflation? "},{"start":11.899,"text":"That is a question haunting central bankers right now, given the “disappointing” trajectory of consumer price data in America, among other places. "}],[{"start":20.689999999999998,"text":"It is also worrying politicians such as US President Joe Biden, against a backdrop of a high level of voter discontent about the economy. "},{"start":28.494,"text":"Investors are uneasy too. "},{"start":30.398999999999997,"text":"This week the gold price hit record highs, amid a search for inflation hedges. "}],[{"start":35.29,"text":"This is, in turn, prompting some classic policy responses: on the one hand, the Federal Reserve is pledging to keep rates high to curb demand; on the other, Biden is lashing out against big business for alleged “price gouging” and/or deceptive practices such as “shrinkflation”, or selling fewer goods for the same price. "}],[{"start":53.42,"text":"Cue a recent bizarre spat about the size of a Snickers bar. "},{"start":57.062000000000005,"text":"Biden suggested in his State of the Union speech that these have shrunk; Mars, the maker of Snickers, denies that. "}],[{"start":64.53999999999999,"text":"This war of words makes for colourful debate. "},{"start":67.419,"text":"But as the Fed’s headache deepens, there is a far better way to frame the issue — by invoking what economists call “shrouding”. "},{"start":73.887,"text":"The term refers to the way prices are presented to, and concealed from, consumers, and has been widely studied by behavioural economists. "}],[{"start":82.52,"text":"Back in the 1980s, for example, the late Daniel Kahneman worked with Amos Tversky to explore “price partitioning”, or how companies sometimes price products in multiple steps, making it hard for consumers to evaluate costs in a “rational” manner. "}],[{"start":96.42999999999999,"text":"Hotel rooms are one example from the service sector: a low initial charge might carry subsequent high additional fees. "},{"start":103.12199999999999,"text":"Printers are another: a cheap printing device might require expensive ink cartridges, the cost of which are not readily visible upfront. "},{"start":110.339,"text":"Shipping costs are yet another example. "}],[{"start":113.71,"text":"A cynic might shrug at this, and argue that it is just sensible behaviour on the part of profit-seeking companies. "},{"start":119.72699999999999,"text":"Maybe so. "},{"start":120.88199999999999,"text":"Consultants such as Deloitte have offered advice to their clients in recent years about how far companies can use shrouding to raise margins, without sparking a consumer backlash. "},{"start":129.649,"text":"But the mere fact that shrouding still exists in 2024, four decades after Kahneman and others began studying it, underscores three important points. "}],[{"start":138.87,"text":"First, business competition does not always deliver true efficiency; markets can fail. "},{"start":144.362,"text":"Second, this market failure arises because consumers are not the all-knowing rational agents that they appear in economic models. "},{"start":151.217,"text":"They have cognitive biases that lead them to make poor choices and leave them ill-equipped to make judgments about inflation. "}],[{"start":157.96,"text":"And third, digitisation alone does not magically fix these competition problems. "},{"start":162.92700000000002,"text":"Yes, it can create more price transparency in some arenas, such as airline tickets. "},{"start":168.107,"text":"But the internet sometimes creates so much information overload that it can also lead to shrouding, particularly when consumers are busy or poorly educated. "},{"start":175.96200000000002,"text":"Indeed, the image — or illusion — of online transparency can actually make obfuscation worse. "}],[{"start":183.05,"text":"Measuring the cost of this is hard, of course. "},{"start":186.192,"text":"But last month the London-based Behavioural Insights Team had a stab at it, and concluded that British gross domestic product would be 0.2 to 1 per cent (or £5-£23bn) bigger if shrouding did not exist. "}],[{"start":198.73000000000002,"text":"It arrived at that estimate by assuming that true price transparency would enable consumers to buy products and services from more efficient companies, thus raising productivity. "},{"start":207.80900000000003,"text":"However, it also explored another crucial issue: that one of the biggest victims of shrouding is the government, since officials running public procurement programmes also struggle to judge the true cost of the services they acquire. "}],[{"start":220.00000000000003,"text":"It follows that efficiency and efficacy would rise for the public and private sectors alike if there were anti-shrouding policies. "},{"start":226.72900000000004,"text":"These could include measures to impose standardised labelling for products and support price comparison websites, consumer advisory services and so on. "}],[{"start":235.68000000000004,"text":"Some free-market economists will undoubtedly wince at this and see it as unwarranted meddling, although BIT says such measures would simply “improv[e] how markets work, unleash innovation and creativity, and help people to make better choices for themselves”. "}],[{"start":249.94000000000003,"text":"Either way, American policymakers and pundits should heed this kind of research. "},{"start":254.59400000000002,"text":"After all, Biden is not the only politician wailing about inflation and alleged price gouging. "},{"start":259.91200000000003,"text":"Donald Trump, the presumptive Republican presidential nominee, has expressed similar sentiments in the past. "}],[{"start":266.18,"text":"That is unsurprising, given that bashing big business is often a vote-winner. "},{"start":270.759,"text":"However, it would be preferable for policymakers to find practical ways to support better price transparency, rather than terrorising the C-suite. "},{"start":278.714,"text":"The latter hurts confidence, while the former might actually improve competition and market functioning in ways that reduce prices. "}],[{"start":286.1,"text":"To put it another way: if Washington wants to make sense of price trends, it needs to take a leaf out of Kahneman’s book and recognise that the perversity of human behaviour endures even in a digital world. "},{"start":296.504,"text":"That might not be enough to end those Snickers wars. "},{"start":299.297,"text":"But it would at least lead to a vision of economics more in tune with how companies, consumers and voters actually behave. "}],[{"start":305.44,"text":""}]],"url":"https://creatives.ftacademy.cn/album/149141-1712299546.mp3"}

版权声明:本文版权归FT中文网所有,未经允许任何单位或个人不得转载,复制或以任何其他方式使用本文全部或部分,侵权必究。

你是否应该在股指创新高时买入?

这感觉很不对,但投资者(包括我)不必太担心。

詹姆斯•克莱弗利:“我一直说没有多少选票可以玩……”

这位政治家首次谈到他是如何在一夜之间从保守党领袖竞选的领先者意外地获得第三名的。

一周新闻小测:2024年11月2日

您对本周的全球重大新闻了解如何?来做个小测试吧!

美国大选的第二天会发生什么?

历史上最紧张的总统竞选之一可能不会在晚上结束,随后可能会出现多重危机。

唐纳德•特朗普说利兹•切尼是“战争鹰派”,应该“被枪指着”

共和党候选人对政治对手的措辞引发新争论。

孟加拉国的意外革命者:一名84岁的老人和一些学生

年轻的抗议者推举诺贝尔奖得主尤努斯担任看守领导人。但改革国家民主体制的时间已经不多了。
设置字号×
最小
较小
默认
较大
最大
分享×